Why I walked away from my legal career to make video games

By Nick Pearce, 6 October 2018

Before I founded Modern Storyteller and began making The Forgotten City, I was working as a legal and strategy advisor to a multi-billion dollar tech company. Yes, that is a bizarre career change, and yes, I completely understand why it leaves a lot of people scratching their heads. It’s extremely unusual to walk away from an established professional career path to enter into an inherently risky industry, where studios rise and fall constantly, and most indie games fail to turn a profit. So why did I do it?

Back in 2012 I was working in a field called Regulatory Strategy. Don’t worry, nobody knows what that means. All you need to know is that when I explained it to people at BBQs, they had no follow-up questions. It was a good traditional career path, but it left me with a lot of unused creative energy. So I decided to pour that energy into a passion project in my spare time.

That passion project was my mod, The Forgotten City, which has now been downloaded over 1.7 million times (at the time of writing), won a national Writers’ Guild award,and has received critical acclaim from the likes of PC Gamer, Kotaku, IGN, among others. I never expected it to become so popular. All I did was make the kind of game I wanted to play; one that respected the intelligence of players by presenting them with a complex interpersonal problem and giving them the freedom to solve it however they felt was best. It didn’t hold anyone’s hand. It punished players for making stupid decisions or trying to rely on brute force, and rewarded them for thinking laterally. I was amazed that it resonated with so many people. On reflection, I think there are a lot of intelligent gamers out there who are being ignored by big game studios, which are simplifying their games in an attempt to appeal to the broadest possible audience.

Back when I was making the mod, I could have happily worked on it all day, every day.  It lit up parts of my brain that had been asleep all my life. Through trial and error, I learned level design, programming, story writing, casting, directing and mastering audio, among other things. It was a revelation to me that I could learn all these skills as and when I needed them. I felt like Neo plugging into the Matrix. I’d never been able to do that before. Why? Because I’d discovered something about which I was truly passionate. But I had a demanding job to go to, so I could only work on it in my precious spare time. So I worked on it for an average of 11 hours every week, for 3 years, totalling 1,700 hours in the end. As much as I loved it, working that hard is crazy, particularly as in the end, fewer than 0.01% of mod users donated. It became clear that modding wasn’t going to be sustainable in the long term.

Still, a lot of people wanted to know what I was going to make next, and I had to make a decision: game development or legal career? I knew that going to work for an established studio wasn’t an option, since I’m committed to living in Australia, where I just couldn’t see a viable career path for myself. Then I met some developers who encouraged me to start my own studio. At first I laughed it off, but I thought about it, from every possible angle, for about a year. I did my research, chatted with various developers, and spoke to my wife at length. I knew it would be hugely risky, since indie games tend to cost a small fortune to make, most of them don’t turn a profit, and the market becomes more crowded every year.

It was a classic head vs heart dilemma. Rationally, I knew I had a good traditional career which had taken me 10 years to build, and if I took a break from it, I might never be able to go back. But I had a burning desire to keep making games, and I’d connected with a market of intelligent gamers who kept asking about my next project.

I was on that precipice, agonizing over whether to take the leap, when I discovered I won a national Writers’ Guild award. A good friend told me at the time: “If there is a God, right now he’s going: Nick, how many signs do I need to give you?!”

I don’t believe in God, but I believe that playing it safe all your life and refusing to take any risks is, itself, an act of risk-taking. What if you spend the rest of your life wondering what would have happened if you had pursued your passion?

So, with the backing of my awesome wife, I took the leap.

So far, I have no regrets. We’ve had some wins already; I managed to recruit some seriously talented people to my team like Alex Goss, Ben Roach, Laura Michet and Michael Allen. We’ve received funding from the wonderful Film Victoria, and we were invited to reveal our game on stage at E3 and even won an Unreal E3 award. But there’s still a long journey ahead of us before we release The Forgotten City in 2019.

This blog will document that journey. I hope you’ll join us along the way. 


Note: If you haven’t yet added The Forgotten City to your Steam wishlist, you can do that here. You’ll be notified automatically when we release it!


Nick Pearce, Creative Director, Modern Storyteller


7 thoughts on “Why I walked away from my legal career to make video games

  1. Charles Whitaker says:

    This is a truely amazing story. I’m glad you’ve decided to share. But I still wonder, what got you into game developement? How did you discover you were truely passionate about it?

    • That’s a great question, Charles. I think the answer is probably long enough to be its own separate blog post, so I’ll add that to my list of things to write about next!

  2. Hi there,

    I really enjoyed The Forgotten City and I was excited upon hearing about your next project. Unfortunately I am not a PC player and so I was wondering how likely it is that your up and coming game will be released for console?


    • Hi Heather. We’re considering whether to bring the game to console, but it depends on the level of interest. If you’re interested, you can add your email address to our petition at forgottencitygame.com/FAQ

  3. While playing the Forgotten city mode, I knew you were passionate about video games and I am proud to say I loved playing it probably as much you loved making it. What are most excited about The Forgotten City coming out as its own game in 2019?

    • That’s a tough one! It’s hard to pick just one thing; the re-written script (this time with professional editing!), the vastly more detailed and beautiful archaeologically authentic game environment, the new characters, the new animations… Too many to list here, but don’t worry, I plan to write about a bunch of different things in future blog posts!

  4. I played the mod some time ago and loved it. It is great to see it becoming its own game and that you are having success so far. May it continue for as long as you care about it. ^_^

    I also must say a thank you for deciding to include choice of race, background and gender – that is, in my opinion, how role-playing should always be approach, from the onset. For me personally it has become a core pillar for games, partly because I have limited funds and therefore must be picky with what I play.

    This one is on my wish list, for certain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>